Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibilitySkip Navigation
401-214-0285
01
02
Start Here

Start with what matters most in your home.

Some homeowners want high style, others want natural materials, and many want something durable and low-maintenance. Start with function to pick the right product type, then use our guidance, in the showroom or online, to nail the style and color.

I Want Something Soft & Comfortable

Carpet brings warmth and quiet to bedrooms, family rooms, and cozy spaces throughout the home.

Comfortable underfoot and quieter than hard surfaces
Great for bedrooms and cozy spaces
Plenty of textures, colors, and performance options
Explore Carpet

I Want Stair Runners

Custom stair runners and stair carpet, measured, bound, and installed by a specialist.

Sisal, wool, and bold patterned looks
Safer, quieter stairs for kids, pets, and adults
Custom binding and fabrication for any staircase
Explore Stair Runners

I Want Real Hardwood

Explore hardwood styles, compare cleaner looks vs more character, and see what fits your space best.

Engineered and solid wood guidance
Clean modern looks or more natural character
Great for long-term value and timeless style
Explore Hardwood

I Want Something Durable & Low-Maintenance

A strong fit for busy homes, everyday wear, and spaces where practicality matters just as much as looks.

Popular for kitchens, rentals, and active homes
Easy to maintain and highly versatile
Great if you want performance without overthinking it
Explore Vinyl Plank

I Want Tile or Natural Stone

Explore tile for floors, backsplashes, bathrooms, kitchens, and other spaces where durability and design both matter.

Great for kitchens, baths, and high-moisture spaces
Wide range of looks, sizes, and patterns
Ideal when you want durability with design flexibility
Explore Tile

Not Sure Yet? See Every Option

Compare all the floor types in one place, or come see them side by side in our Middletown showroom.

Carpet, stair runners, hardwood, vinyl, and tile
Local guidance to narrow it down
Largest selection on the Island
Explore All Floors
★★★★★
Helpful, local guidance beats guessing.

Island Carpet is the kind of store people use when they want real help narrowing things down, not just a wall of samples and a generic sales pitch. That matters when the decision has to fit your home and daily life.

“I’ve worked with Island Carpet for two projects - bathroom tile and carpeting for my stairs. I am thrilled with the results. Great service and selection. Abby was so helpful!” - Sara P.
Since 2004

A true neighborhood flooring store in Middletown with family flooring roots going back to 1927. We take the time to understand your home and how you live, so you end up with a floor that fits and lasts.

Choose a local, family-owned store that takes pride in its work
Why People Choose Local

Good flooring decisions start before the sample leaves the store.

The right floor depends on moisture, wear, stairs, pets, rentals, second homes, and how long you want it to last. That is why good guidance matters so much.

A real local team, real projects, and flooring guidance built around real homes.
Not every floor belongs in every home. The right choice changes based on how the space is used, how much wear it takes, and what you want long term.
The product and the installation need to match. Prep, substrate, moisture conditions, and the installer matter just as much as the product itself.
The right fit lasts. Matching the floor to the room, the traffic, and the installation means it looks right and holds up for years.
Visit Our Showroom

See samples side by side before you decide.

Browsing online helps, but many decisions get much easier once you can compare colors, textures, and finishes in person with someone walking you through the differences.

See colors, textures, and finishes in real life
Compare practical options, better options, and premium styles side by side
Leave with more clarity about what actually fits your home
Get real answers and narrow it down faster.
Ready to Get Started?

Have a question? Call, or stop by the showroom.

You do not need to know the exact product yet. We can help you compare the right options without making the process feel overwhelming.

401-214-0285 Quick question? Start there.